Couche-Tard chairman fails to convince French minister about Carrefour deal


The founder of Alimentation Couche-Tard walked away empty-handed Friday after trying to convince France's finance minister to drop his objection to it acquiring grocery giant Carrefour.

Alain Bouchard met with Bruno Le Maire in Paris. His offer of various commitments was not enough to change Le Maire's opposition over food security issues, according to information obtained by The Canadian Press.

Earlier, the minister expressed concerns about the potential $25 billion transaction.

"My answer is extremely clear: we are not in favour of the deal. The no is polite but it's a clear and final no,'' he said in a television interview.

Quebec Economy and Innovation Minister Pierre Fitzgibbon had said that the convenience store giant would have to demonstrate that food security was not at stake.

"I cannot say that I am surprised (by the reaction of the French government),'' he said in a conference call.

Fitzgibbon said there appears to have been an "agreement in principle'' with senior management at Carrefour and some of its largest shareholders, but the matter turned "political.''

Le Maire's comments prompted Carrefour shares to decrease further below the 20 euro offer. Couche-Tard's shares recovered some of their recent losses, rising 4.7%, or $1.69, to $37.98 in Friday trading on the Toronto Stock Exchange.

The Quebec-based convenience store retailer didn't respond to requests for comment.

Analyst Irene Nattel of RBC Dominion Securities said France's concerns are consistent with previous government posturing to the Pepsi/Danone deal in 2005 and rigorous conditions imposed on GE's acquisition of Alstom's power business.

Alimentation Couche-Tard's interest in Carrefour caught industry analysts by surprise, who questioned the strategic fit between theconvenience store chain and Carrefour, France's largest private-sector employer with more than 100,000 workers.

Founded more than 60 years ago, it operates nearly 13,000 hypermarkets, supermarkets and convenience stores in 30 countries including France, Spain, Italy, Brazil, Argentina and Taiwan. Its global workforce exceeds 320,000 employees.

"We see limited strategic fit for Couche-Tard in acquiring Carrefour due to minimal geographic and business overlap and we expect limited synergies,'' wrote Mark Petrie of CIBC Capital Markets.

Despite the risks, he said the key part of the rationale would be to establish a platform for future consolidation.

"We believe Couche-Tard would likely use the Carrefour asset base to pursue further acquisitions with scale.''

Ultimately, Petrie said regulatory approval is uncertain even though he believes Couche-Tard would offer the French government assurances on food security and supply, as well as job protections.

This ad will auto-close in 10 seconds